Dispute Resolution Options for Pillion Passengers in NSW Motor Accident Claims
A threshold injury under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (NSW) includes a soft tissue injury and a psychological or psychiatric injury that is not a recognised psychiatric illness (adjustment disorder and acute stress disorder are the usual examples; s 1.6 and Motor Accident Guidelines Part 5).
A pillion passenger injured in a motorcycle accident in NSW may seek compensation through the Compulsory Third Party (CTP) insurance scheme. Disputes typically arise over the amount of compensation, the classification of injuries, or the acceptance of liability. Under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAIA), claimants have several formal and informal options to resolve disagreements with insurers or the insurer’s nominated claims assessor. These include internal review processes, formal dispute resolution through the Personal Injury Commission (PIC), and, in limited cases, court proceedings.
Legal Framework for Pillion Passenger Claims
Pillion passengers are covered under the CTP scheme if they were injured in a motor vehicle accident involving a registered motor vehicle. The injury must have occurred during the use of the vehicle on a road or road-related area, including private property used for public access. The CTP scheme provides statutory benefits regardless of fault, including treatment and care benefits, weekly income payments, and, in some cases, damages for non-economic loss.
If the injury is classified as a threshold injury, the claimant may still be eligible for treatment and care benefits and weekly payments, but damages for non-economic loss are generally not available unless the injury exceeds the threshold. The Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017 and the Motor Accident Injuries Guidelines set out the criteria for injury classification, including the requirement for a spinal nerve-root injury to produce neurological signs other than radiculopathy to qualify as a soft-tissue injury.
Practical Steps and Evidence for Dispute Resolution
To resolve a dispute, claimants should first gather and preserve all relevant evidence. This includes:
- Medical records from the initial assessment through to recovery, including diagnostic imaging and specialist reports
- A detailed account of the accident, including the date, time, location, weather, road conditions, and any contributing factors
- Photographs of the scene, vehicle damage, and visible injuries
- Witness contact details and statements
- Records of lost income, out-of-pocket expenses, and any impact on daily activities
- Correspondence with the insurer, including written notices of claim, assessment reports, and responses to offers
If a dispute arises over the insurer’s assessment of injury severity or the amount of compensation offered, the claimant may request an internal review. This must be made within 28 days of receiving the insurer’s decision. The insurer must provide a written response within 28 days of the request.
Formal Dispute Resolution Through the Personal Injury Commission
If an internal review does not resolve the dispute, the claimant may apply to the Personal Injury Commission (PIC) for formal dispute resolution. The PIC is the independent body responsible for resolving disputes under the CTP scheme in NSW. It handles matters involving the assessment of injury, entitlement to benefits, and the calculation of compensation.
The PIC process includes:
- A medical assessment conducted by an independent medical practitioner approved by the Commission
- A review of all submitted evidence, including medical reports, accident details, and financial records
- A written determination issued within 90 days of the application, unless an extension is granted
A claimant may request a review of the PIC’s determination if they believe it was based on an error of law or fact. The review must be made within 28 days of receiving the determination.
Time Limits and Procedural Requirements
Time limits are critical in CTP claims. A claim for compensation must generally be made within three years of the accident date. However, disputes involving medical assessments or benefit entitlements may have shorter internal review deadlines. For example, an internal review request must be made within 28 days of receiving the insurer’s decision. Missing these deadlines may result in the claim being barred.
A claimant who has not received a decision on a claim within 90 days of submission may apply to the PIC for a review of the insurer’s inaction. The PIC may order the insurer to provide a decision within a specified timeframe.
Hypothetical Example: Resolving a Dispute Over Injury Classification
A pillion passenger was injured in a collision on a suburban road in Greater Sydney. The insurer accepted liability but disputed the classification of a neck injury as a threshold injury. The claimant’s treating physician diagnosed a soft-tissue injury with neurological signs, but the insurer’s medical assessor concluded the injury did not meet the threshold criteria.
The claimant requested an internal review, which was denied. They then applied to the PIC for dispute resolution. The PIC arranged for an independent medical assessment, which confirmed the presence of a spinal nerve-root injury with neurological signs consistent with the Motor Accident Injuries Guidelines. The PIC upheld the claimant’s position and ordered the insurer to provide treatment and care benefits and weekly payments.
When to Seek Independent Legal Advice
While the CTP scheme provides a structured process for dispute resolution, the outcome depends on the strength of the evidence and the accuracy of medical assessments. A claimant should consider seeking independent advice if:
- The insurer disputes a diagnosis or the severity of an injury
- The claim is denied or limited despite strong medical evidence
- The insurer refuses to provide a decision within the required timeframe
Legal advice can help identify procedural rights, assess the strength of a claim, and ensure that all evidence is properly presented to the PIC or a court.
Every claim depends on its own facts. To request contact about your circumstances, complete the quick, no obligation enquiry form.